Ethical considerations of athlete’s health data

Professional sports have always been at the forefront of innovation, seeking new and better ways to enhance performance and gain a competitive edge. One area that has received increased attention in recent years is the use of health data to monitor and optimize athlete performance. However, the use of health data in professional sports raises a number of ethical concerns that need to be addressed.

In their article "The Use of Health Data in Professional Sport: A Review of the Current Status and Ethical Concerns," (published in the journal The Physician and Sportsmedicine in 2016) Paul Dimeo and Verner Moller provide a comprehensive review of the health data use in professional sports, as well as the ethical concerns associated with its use.

One of the main areas of focus in the use of health data in professional sports is the use of wearable technology. This includes devices such as heart rate monitors, GPS tracking, and accelerometers, which can provide real-time data on an athlete's physical performance and health status. This data can be used to optimize training and recovery, as well as to identify potential injury risks.

However, the use of wearable technology raises a number of ethical concerns, including issues of privacy and confidentiality. Athletes may be uncomfortable with the level of monitoring that these devices provide, and there is a risk that the data collected could be used against them in ways that they did not intend. Additionally, there are concerns around data ownership and control, with questions over who owns the data collected and who has access to it.

Another area of concern is the use of electronic medical records (EMRs) in professional sports. EMRs can provide a comprehensive record of an athlete's medical history, as well as information on any injuries or illnesses they may have experienced. However, there are concerns around the security of this data, and the potential for it to be used against athletes in ways that they did not intend.

Use of wearable technology raises a number of ethical concerns, including issues of privacy and confidentiality

Overall, the use of health data in professional sports has the potential to provide significant benefits, both in terms of enhancing performance and improving athlete health. However, it is important that these benefits are balanced against the ethical concerns that arise from the use of this data. As Dimeo and Moller note, "the ethical issues associated with the use of health data in professional sport are complex and multifaceted, and require careful consideration from all stakeholders." By addressing these concerns in a transparent and responsible manner, the use of health data in professional sports will be beneficial for all involved.

In addition to the ethical concerns raised by Dimeo and Moller, Matthew R. Stults-Kolehmainen's article "Ethical considerations for the use of health-related data in athlete monitoring" (published in Current Opinion in Physiology in 2019), adds further insights. One of the key issues raised by Stults-Kolehmainen is the importance of informed consent in the collection and use of health data.

Athletes need to be fully informed of what data is being collected, how it will be used, and who will have access to it. They should also have the ability to withdraw their consent at any time if they feel uncomfortable with the level of monitoring or the use of their data. Additionally, Stults-Kolehmainen highlights the importance of ensuring that the data collected is accurate and reliable, and that it is used in a manner that respects athletes' privacy and confidentiality.

Ultimately, the use of health data in professional sports requires a delicate balance between the potential benefits and the ethical concerns that arise from its use. By adopting a transparent and responsible approach to the collection and use of health data, we can ensure that athletes' privacy and rights are respected, while still reaping the benefits that health data can provide for athlete monitoring and optimization. After all, it is the athlete's data we are talking about. He or she should have control of it. Not anyone else. 

‍